The Fake “Mrs Surat”

In the aftermath of Lincoln’s assassination, photographs of the assassin were highly sought after. Newspaper classifieds of the day often contained advertisements for Lincoln memorial ribbons right beside advertisements offering photographs of John Wilkes Booth.

JWB photos ad 1

The lucrative business of assassination related imagery extended not only to photographs of the assassin, but also to his conspirators. As a result, photographer Alexander Gardner was quick to reproduce his mugshot photographs of the accused conspirators into carte de visites for the masses to purchase:

However, two of the conspirators who were put on trial, Dr. Samuel Mudd and Mary Surratt, never had their photographs taken with the rest of the conspirators.  While the public could easily do without a picture of Dr. Mudd (himself little more than another male face in Booth’s crew) the desire to see and own a picture of the solitary woman accused of helping plot the death of the President was something worth attaining. One would think that the lack of a legitimate mugshot photograph of Mary Surratt would hinder the creation of a massively produced CDV like the ones pictured above. However, such trivialities did not stop some unknown photographer from creating and selling the following CDVs of Mary Surratt:
Fake Mary Surratt CDV BoothieBarn

The small details of spelling Mary Surratt’s name correctly or attempting to find an actual likeness of the conspirator were not important to the photographer who created these fabricated CDVS. The public purchased and filled their albums with these fraudulent “Mrs Surat” images, with most having no idea that the woman pictured was not the assassin’s accomplice. The identity of this “Mrs Surat” has not been determined, but she bears very little resemblance to the true Mrs. Surratt:

Mary Surratt's CDV 1

Despite being fake, these period “Mrs Surat” CDVS are still sought after by collectors and can often sell for more money than legitimate images of John Wilkes Booth himself.

At the end of the day,  “Mrs Surat” is a perfect example of America’s unwavering devotion to the entrepreneurial spirit and the old adage, “Caveat emptor” – Buyer beware!

For more pictures of Mary Surratt, check out the Mary Surratt Picture Gallery.

Categories: History, Uncategorized | Tags: | 7 Comments

Post navigation

7 thoughts on “The Fake “Mrs Surat”

  1. That cdv of “Mrs. Surat” recently sold on eBay for $224.50. I kept following the listing and was shocked it sold for that much lol!

  2. That’s pretty sad….and scary! “Caveat emptor” indeed….unless one is into buying fakes!

    • I didn’t see the recent cdv that sold on ebay but, naturally you are going to dispute the cdv as being mrs. Surratt just as you did a couple of my “tintypes” I have of mrs. Surratt that I still firmly without a doubt believe is mary Surratt. come to think of it, you disputed all of my tintype photos of jwb, paine, herold, etc, etc.. that I shared with you several years back but it didn’t then and doesn’t now change my opinion of my old photos. sorry but, you just can’t be right all the time unless you are an expert in facial

      • Paul T Fisher

        Bear in mind, facial recognition experts did an analysis of photos of John Wilkes Booth compared to John St. Helen and called it a close match. Anyone looking at the photos can see that many of the facial features are nowhere near being a match. I won’t get into the specific differences here, but they are numerous!

  3. Paul Fisher

    Looks like Clara Barton’s plain sister.

  4. Dennis Urban

    Also recently, a CDV advertised as JWB’s boot cut by Dr. Mudd, was auctioned on E-Bay and went for a significant price. The CDV was NOT of the actual boot. Any one with decent historical knowledge would have seen through that image.

  5. Pingback: The Fake David Herold | BoothieBarn

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: